Documento - Amnesty International’s wrap-up statement on some of the developments at the 21st session of the UN Human Rights Council

</head> <body> <p> <img src="embedded:image1.wmf" alt="image1.wmf"/> </p> <p/> <p/> <p/> <p> <b>Amnesty International’s wrap-up statement on some of the developments at the 21st session of the UN Human Rights Council (10-28 September 2012) (<i>Not delivered)</i> </b> </p> <p/> <p>AI Index: IOR 41/025/2012 </p> <p>28 September 2012</p> <p/> <p>Item1: Organizational and procedural matters </p> <p> <i>General comments from stakeholders</i> </p> <p/> <p>Madam President, </p> <p/> <p>This session has seen numerous positive developments, including in connection with the safety of journalists, human rights and preventable maternal mortality and morbidity, human rights and extreme poverty, and Syria. </p> <p/> <p>Amnesty International welcomes the Council’s decision to provide for public follow-up to its consideration of Eritrea under the confidential Complaint Procedure. This is an important example of how the Council can fulfill its mandate to follow methods of work that ‘allow for subsequent follow-up discussions to recommendations and their implementation’.�</p> <p>Tentative efforts were made to address recent despicable instances of deliberately provocative vilifications of Islam and Muslims. However, the social, political and legal issues raised by such acts and deliberately violent responses to them are too important to be addressed in haste. Time must be made to address those issues calmly, deliberately and with determination in an effort to find effective and lasting responses. </p> <p/> <p>Amnesty International welcomes, inter alia, that for the first time no delegation opposed the reaffirmation of the right to sanitation and the reaffirmation that the right to safe drinking water and sanitation is derived from the right to an adequate standard of living. We regret, however, that countries most supportive of these rights allowed the negotiation of the resolution to be dominated by the countries that have only recently recognised them. The latecomers managed to ensure the exclusion of important elements from the resolution, such as the specification of the elements of the rights to water and sanitation and recommendations relating to the provision of water and sanitation to informal settlements. Amnesty International urges State supporters of the rights to water and sanitation to be vigilant and actively counter future attempts to restrict the scope of these rights. </p> <p> </p> <p>Madam President, </p> <p/> <p>At this session one delegation urged that the distinction between a country situation under item 4 and item 10 be kept clear as that distinction is essential for building trust and confidence among States for enhancing the Council’s work on technical assistance and capacity building. </p> <p/> <p>Amnesty International agrees. Item 10 should be used for countries that would do better but need help. Using it to deal with situations where the government deliberately commits gross and systematic human rights violations abuses this Council and is a further affront to the dignity of the persons suffering the violations. </p> <p/> <p>For example, civilians suffering deliberate ongoing indiscriminate aerial bombardments by the security forces of their own government and humanitarian workers in those areas would surely wonder whether talk of technical assistance to protect them is a sick joke. </p> <p/> <p>Those persons would wonder how this Council could yet again reward a government that has already been given many chances to prove its stated readiness to improve the country’s human rights situation and fulfill its human rights obligation, but continues to engage in deliberate human rights violations, has refused to undertake essential human rights reforms and has even gone as far as preventing the Council from being kept informed of the human rights situation. </p> <p/> <p>They would wonder why this Council has yet again given an Independent Expert the impossible task of having assisting a government to end human rights violations that it has manifestly no will to stop. </p> <p/> <p>Yes the government of Sudan fooled the Commission on Human Rights in 2003, and shame on Sudan. Sudan continues to fool this Council in 2012, and shame on this Council. </p> <p/> <p>Thank you Madam President. </p> <p/> </body> </html> <div class="messages noicon"><h2><a href="/es/library/info/IOR41/025/2012/en">View the overview page for this document</a></h2></div> </div> </div> </div></div> <!-- /squeeze /main --> <div id="ai-sidebar-last" class="column ai-sidebar"> <div class="panel-pane pane-block pane-amnestyblocks-print-email" id="block-amnesty-print_email"> <div class="pane-content"> <ul class="print-email"><li class="0 first last active"><a href="/es/library/asset/IOR41/025/2012/en/b9dfcf35-4127-4af8-a089-86969919f9e1/ior410252012en.html" onclick="javascript:window.print();return false;" class="print-link active">Imprimir</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="panel-region-separator"></div><div class="panel-pane pane-block pane-block-33" id="how-you-can-help-home"> <h2 class="pane-title">Cómo puedes ayudar</h2> <div class="pane-content"> <p><a href="/es/donate" title="Ayuda a poner fin a los abusos de derechos humanos.">Haz un donativo</a></p> <p><a href="/es/join" title="Defiende los derechos humanos en todo el mundo.">Únete</a></p> <p><a href="/es/activism-center" title="Actúa">Actúa</a></p> </div> </div> <div class="panel-region-separator"></div><div class="panel-pane pane-block pane-amnestyblocks-country-contact-dropdown" > <h2 class="pane-title">AMNISTÍA INTERNACIONAL EN EL MUNDO</h2> <div class="pane-content"> <!--googleoff: all--><form action="/es/country/goto/contact" accept-charset="UTF-8" method="post" id="amnesty-country-contact-select-form" class=""> <div><div class="form-item" id="edit-country-wrapper"> <select name="country" onchange="submitDropdown(this);" class="form-select" id="edit-country" ><option value="0">Seleccionar país</option><option value="1401">Afganistán</option><option value="1595">Albania</option><option value="1579">Alemania</option><option value="1585">Andorra</option><option value="1513">Angola</option><option value="1474">Anguila</option><option value="1671">Antigua y Barbuda</option><option value="1471">Antillas</option><option value="1562">Arabia Saudí</option><option value="1557">Argelia</option><option value="1649">Argentina</option><option value="1611">Armenia</option><option value="1632">Australia</option><option value="1584">Austria</option><option value="1559">Autoridad Palestina</option><option value="1610">Azerbaiyán</option><option value="1467">Bahamas</option><option value="1566">Bahréin</option><option value="1399">Bangladesh</option><option value="1670">Barbados</option><option value="1583">Bélgica</option><option value="1655">Belice</option><option value="1679">Benín</option><option value="1669">Bermudas</option><option value="1609">Bielorrusia</option><option value="1648">Bolivia</option><option value="1739">Bosnia y Herzegovina</option><option value="1511">Botsuana</option><option value="1647">Brasil</option><option value="1631">Brunéi Darussalam</option><option value="1594">Bulgaria</option><option value="1493">Burkina Faso</option><option value="1537">Burundi</option><option value="1636">Bután</option><option value="1678">Cabo Verde</option><option value="1630">Camboya</option><option value="1696">Camerún</option><option value="1431">Canadá</option><option value="1694">Chad</option><option value="1646">Chile</option><option value="1639">China</option><option value="1592">Chipre</option><option value="1645">Colombia</option><option value="1693">Comoras</option><option value="1785">Corea del Norte</option><option value="1781">Corea del Sur</option><option value="1793">Costa de Marfil</option><option value="1441">Costa Rica</option><option value="1593">Croacia</option><option value="1462">Cuba</option><option value="1582">Dinamarca</option><option value="1667">Dominica</option><option value="1644">Ecuador</option><option value="1554">Egipto</option><option value="1654">El Salvador</option><option value="1563">Emiratos Árabes Unidos</option><option value="1691">Eritrea</option><option value="1587">Eslovenia</option><option value="1570">España</option><option value="1650">Estados Unidos</option><option value="1614">Estonia</option><option value="1690">Etiopía</option><option value="1363">Filipinas</option><option value="1580">Finlandia</option><option value="1628">Fiyi</option><option value="1314">Francia</option><option value="1528">Gabón</option><option value="1677">Gambia</option><option value="1608">Georgia</option><option value="1489">Ghana</option><option value="1311">Gibraltar</option><option value="1665">Granada</option><option value="1591">Grecia</option><option value="1578">Groenlandia</option><option value="1457">Guadalupe</option><option value="1381">Guam</option><option value="1653">Guatemala</option><option value="1676">Guinea</option><option value="1692">Guinea Ecuatorial</option><option value="1789">Guinea-Bissau</option><option value="1420">Guyana</option><option value="1642">Guyana Francesa</option><option value="1664">Haití</option><option value="1437">Honduras</option><option value="1409">Hong Kong</option><option value="1600">Hungría</option><option value="1635">India</option><option value="1626">Indonesia</option><option value="1565">Irak</option><option value="1286">Irán</option><option value="1576">Irlanda</option><option value="1577">Islandia</option><option value="1668">Islas Caimán</option><option value="1629">Islas Cook</option><option value="1581">Islas Feroe</option><option value="1643">Islas Malvinas</option><option value="1624">Islas Marshall</option><option value="2844">Islas Pitcairn</option><option value="1617">Islas Salomón</option><option value="1658">Islas Turcas y Caicos</option><option value="1656">Islas Vírgenes Británicas</option><option value="1657">Islas Vírgenes de Estados Unidos</option><option value="1733">Israel y los Territorios Palestinos Ocupados</option><option value="1575">Italia</option><option value="1663">Jamaica</option><option value="1638">Japón</option><option value="1560">Jordania</option><option value="1607">Kazajistán</option><option value="1522">Kenia</option><option value="1606">Kirguistán</option><option value="1378">Kiribati</option><option value="1564">Kuwait</option><option value="1376">Laos</option><option value="1684">Lesoto</option><option value="1613">Letonia</option><option value="1558">Líbano</option><option value="1675">Liberia</option><option value="1555">Libia</option><option value="1305">Liechtenstein</option><option value="1612">Lituania</option><option value="1303">Luxemburgo</option><option value="1406">Macao</option><option value="1590">Macedonia</option><option value="1520">Madagascar</option><option value="1625">Malaisia</option><option value="1508">Malawi</option><option value="1395">Maldivas</option><option value="1485">Malí</option><option value="1574">Malta</option><option value="1737">Marruecos y el Sáhara Occidental</option><option value="1453">Martinica</option><option value="1689">Mauricio</option><option value="1674">Mauritania</option><option value="1652">México</option><option value="1623">Micronesia</option><option value="1605">Moldavia</option><option value="1300">Mónaco</option><option value="1637">Mongolia</option><option value="1589">Montenegro</option><option value="1451">Montserrat</option><option value="1506">Mozambique</option><option value="1371">Myanmar</option><option value="1683">Namibia</option><option value="1369">Nauru</option><option value="1634">Nepal</option><option value="1434">Nicaragua</option><option value="1482">Níger</option><option value="1673">Nigeria</option><option value="1620">Niue</option><option value="1572">Noruega</option><option value="1622">Nueva Caledonia</option><option value="1621">Nueva Zelanda</option><option value="1281">Omán</option><option value="1573">Países Bajos</option><option value="1392">Pakistán</option><option value="2853">Palau</option><option value="1651">Panamá</option><option value="1619">Papúa Nueva Guinea</option><option value="1418">Paraguay</option><option value="1641">Perú</option><option value="1627">Polinesia Francesa</option><option value="1599">Polonia</option><option value="1296">Portugal</option><option value="1662">Puerto Rico</option><option value="1279">Qatar</option><option value="1567">Reino Unido</option><option value="1695">República Centroafricana</option><option value="1601">República Checa</option><option value="1531">República del Congo</option><option value="1797">República Democrática del Congo</option><option value="1666">República Dominicana</option><option value="1596">República Eslovaca</option><option value="1682">Reunión</option><option value="1526">Ruanda</option><option value="1598">Rumania</option><option value="1597">Rusia</option><option value="2841">Samoa</option><option value="1633">Samoa</option><option value="2838">San Cristóbal y Nieves</option><option value="1571">San Marino</option><option value="1660">San Vicente</option><option value="1661">Santa Lucía</option><option value="2847">Santo Tomé y Príncipe</option><option value="1672">Senegal</option><option value="1588">Serbia</option><option value="1502">Seychelles</option><option value="1478">Sierra Leona</option><option value="1618">Singapur</option><option value="1556">Siria</option><option value="1688">Somalia</option><option value="1390">Sri Lanka</option><option value="1499">Suazilandia</option><option value="1681">Sudáfrica</option><option value="1687">Sudán</option><option value="25680">Sudán del Sur</option><option value="1569">Suecia</option><option value="1568">Suiza</option><option value="1415">Surinam</option><option value="1616">Tailandia</option><option value="1403">Taiwán</option><option value="1686">Tanzania</option><option value="1604">Tayikistán</option><option value="1743">Timor Oriental</option><option value="1476">Togo</option><option value="1358">Tonga</option><option value="1659">Trinidad y Tobago</option><option value="1553">Túnez</option><option value="1603">Turkmenistán</option><option value="1586">Turquía</option><option value="1356">Tuvalu</option><option value="1339">Ucrania</option><option value="1685">Uganda</option><option value="1413">Uruguay</option><option value="1602">Uzbekistán</option><option value="1354">Vanuatu</option><option value="1289">Vaticano</option><option value="1640">Venezuela</option><option value="1615">Vietnam</option><option value="1561">Yemen</option><option value="2850">Yibuti</option><option value="1680">Zambia</option><option value="1496">Zimbabue</option></select> </div> <input type="submit" name="op" id="edit-submit" value="Ir" class="form-submit" /> <input type="hidden" name="form_build_id" id="form-3691ebec9f04af3441a12320d1f0bdf4" value="form-3691ebec9f04af3441a12320d1f0bdf4" /> <input type="hidden" name="form_id" id="edit-amnesty-country-contact-select-form" value="amnesty_country_contact_select_form" /> </div></form> <!--googleon: all--> </div> </div> </div> <!-- /ai-sidebar-last --> </div> </div> <!-- /container --> <br class="panel-clearer" /> <div id="footer-wrapper"> <div id="footer"> <div id="footer-copyright"> © 2014 Amnistía Internacional </div> <ul class="menu"><li class="leaf first"><a href="http://www.amnistiainternacional.org/" title="Librería online"><span class="menu-arrow">›</span> <span class="tab">Librería online</span></a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/es/privacy-policy" title="Política de privacidad"><span class="menu-arrow">›</span> Política de privacidad</a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/es/accessibility" title="Accesibilidad"><span class="menu-arrow">›</span> Accesibilidad</a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/es/cookies-statement"><span class="menu-arrow">›</span> Cookies</a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/es/contact" title="Contacto"><span class="menu-arrow">›</span> Contacto</a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/es/worldwide-sites" title="Amnistía Internacional en el mundo"><span class="menu-arrow">›</span> Amnistía Internacional en el mundo</a></li> <li class="leaf"><a href="/es/site_map" title="Mapa del sitio"><span class="menu-arrow">›</span> Mapa del sitio</a></li> <li class="leaf last"><a href="http://careers.amnesty.org/" title=""><span class="menu-arrow">›</span> <span class="tab">Empleo</span></a></li> </ul> </div> <!-- /footer --> </div> <!-- /footer-wrapper --> <div id="header-country-dropdown"><!--googleoff: all--><form action="/es/country/goto/contact" accept-charset="UTF-8" method="post" id="amnesty-header-country-select-form" class=""> <div><div class="form-item" id="edit-country-contact-wrapper"> <label for="edit-country-contact">En tu país: </label> <select name="country_contact" onchange="submitDropdown(this);" class="form-select" id="edit-country-contact" ><option value="0">Selecciona un país</option><option value="1401">Afganistán</option><option value="1595">Albania</option><option value="1579">Alemania</option><option value="1585">Andorra</option><option value="1513">Angola</option><option value="1474">Anguila</option><option value="1671">Antigua y Barbuda</option><option value="1471">Antillas</option><option value="1562">Arabia Saudí</option><option value="1557">Argelia</option><option value="1649">Argentina</option><option value="1611">Armenia</option><option value="1632">Australia</option><option value="1584">Austria</option><option value="1559">Autoridad Palestina</option><option value="1610">Azerbaiyán</option><option value="1467">Bahamas</option><option value="1566">Bahréin</option><option value="1399">Bangladesh</option><option value="1670">Barbados</option><option value="1583">Bélgica</option><option value="1655">Belice</option><option value="1679">Benín</option><option value="1669">Bermudas</option><option value="1609">Bielorrusia</option><option value="1648">Bolivia</option><option value="1739">Bosnia y Herzegovina</option><option value="1511">Botsuana</option><option value="1647">Brasil</option><option value="1631">Brunéi Darussalam</option><option value="1594">Bulgaria</option><option value="1493">Burkina Faso</option><option value="1537">Burundi</option><option value="1636">Bután</option><option value="1678">Cabo Verde</option><option value="1630">Camboya</option><option value="1696">Camerún</option><option value="1431">Canadá</option><option value="1694">Chad</option><option value="1646">Chile</option><option value="1639">China</option><option value="1592">Chipre</option><option value="1645">Colombia</option><option value="1693">Comoras</option><option value="1785">Corea del Norte</option><option value="1781">Corea del Sur</option><option value="1793">Costa de Marfil</option><option value="1441">Costa Rica</option><option value="1593">Croacia</option><option value="1462">Cuba</option><option value="1582">Dinamarca</option><option value="1667">Dominica</option><option value="1644">Ecuador</option><option value="1554">Egipto</option><option value="1654">El Salvador</option><option value="1563">Emiratos Árabes Unidos</option><option value="1691">Eritrea</option><option value="1587">Eslovenia</option><option value="1570">España</option><option value="1650">Estados Unidos</option><option value="1614">Estonia</option><option value="1690">Etiopía</option><option value="1363">Filipinas</option><option value="1580">Finlandia</option><option value="1628">Fiyi</option><option value="1314">Francia</option><option value="1528">Gabón</option><option value="1677">Gambia</option><option value="1608">Georgia</option><option value="1489">Ghana</option><option value="1311">Gibraltar</option><option value="1665">Granada</option><option value="1591">Grecia</option><option value="1578">Groenlandia</option><option value="1457">Guadalupe</option><option value="1381">Guam</option><option value="1653">Guatemala</option><option value="1676">Guinea</option><option value="1692">Guinea Ecuatorial</option><option value="1789">Guinea-Bissau</option><option value="1420">Guyana</option><option value="1642">Guyana Francesa</option><option value="1664">Haití</option><option value="1437">Honduras</option><option value="1409">Hong Kong</option><option value="1600">Hungría</option><option value="1635">India</option><option value="1626">Indonesia</option><option value="1565">Irak</option><option value="1286">Irán</option><option value="1576">Irlanda</option><option value="1577">Islandia</option><option value="1668">Islas Caimán</option><option value="1629">Islas Cook</option><option value="1581">Islas Feroe</option><option value="1643">Islas Malvinas</option><option value="1624">Islas Marshall</option><option value="2844">Islas Pitcairn</option><option value="1617">Islas Salomón</option><option value="1658">Islas Turcas y Caicos</option><option value="1656">Islas Vírgenes Británicas</option><option value="1657">Islas Vírgenes de Estados Unidos</option><option value="1733">Israel y los Territorios Palestinos Ocupados</option><option value="1575">Italia</option><option value="1663">Jamaica</option><option value="1638">Japón</option><option value="1560">Jordania</option><option value="1607">Kazajistán</option><option value="1522">Kenia</option><option value="1606">Kirguistán</option><option value="1378">Kiribati</option><option value="1564">Kuwait</option><option value="1376">Laos</option><option value="1684">Lesoto</option><option value="1613">Letonia</option><option value="1558">Líbano</option><option value="1675">Liberia</option><option value="1555">Libia</option><option value="1305">Liechtenstein</option><option value="1612">Lituania</option><option value="1303">Luxemburgo</option><option value="1406">Macao</option><option value="1590">Macedonia</option><option value="1520">Madagascar</option><option value="1625">Malaisia</option><option value="1508">Malawi</option><option value="1395">Maldivas</option><option value="1485">Malí</option><option value="1574">Malta</option><option value="1737">Marruecos y el Sáhara Occidental</option><option value="1453">Martinica</option><option value="1689">Mauricio</option><option value="1674">Mauritania</option><option value="1652">México</option><option value="1623">Micronesia</option><option value="1605">Moldavia</option><option value="1300">Mónaco</option><option value="1637">Mongolia</option><option value="1589">Montenegro</option><option value="1451">Montserrat</option><option value="1506">Mozambique</option><option value="1371">Myanmar</option><option value="1683">Namibia</option><option value="1369">Nauru</option><option value="1634">Nepal</option><option value="1434">Nicaragua</option><option value="1482">Níger</option><option value="1673">Nigeria</option><option value="1620">Niue</option><option value="1572">Noruega</option><option value="1622">Nueva Caledonia</option><option value="1621">Nueva Zelanda</option><option value="1281">Omán</option><option value="1573">Países Bajos</option><option value="1392">Pakistán</option><option value="2853">Palau</option><option value="1651">Panamá</option><option value="1619">Papúa Nueva Guinea</option><option value="1418">Paraguay</option><option value="1641">Perú</option><option value="1627">Polinesia Francesa</option><option value="1599">Polonia</option><option value="1296">Portugal</option><option value="1662">Puerto Rico</option><option value="1279">Qatar</option><option value="1567">Reino Unido</option><option value="1695">República Centroafricana</option><option value="1601">República Checa</option><option value="1531">República del Congo</option><option value="1797">República Democrática del Congo</option><option value="1666">República Dominicana</option><option value="1596">República Eslovaca</option><option value="1682">Reunión</option><option value="1526">Ruanda</option><option value="1598">Rumania</option><option value="1597">Rusia</option><option value="2841">Samoa</option><option value="1633">Samoa</option><option value="2838">San Cristóbal y Nieves</option><option value="1571">San Marino</option><option value="1660">San Vicente</option><option value="1661">Santa Lucía</option><option value="2847">Santo Tomé y Príncipe</option><option value="1672">Senegal</option><option value="1588">Serbia</option><option value="1502">Seychelles</option><option value="1478">Sierra Leona</option><option value="1618">Singapur</option><option value="1556">Siria</option><option value="1688">Somalia</option><option value="1390">Sri Lanka</option><option value="1499">Suazilandia</option><option value="1681">Sudáfrica</option><option value="1687">Sudán</option><option value="25680">Sudán del Sur</option><option value="1569">Suecia</option><option value="1568">Suiza</option><option value="1415">Surinam</option><option value="1616">Tailandia</option><option value="1403">Taiwán</option><option value="1686">Tanzania</option><option value="1604">Tayikistán</option><option value="1743">Timor Oriental</option><option value="1476">Togo</option><option value="1358">Tonga</option><option value="1659">Trinidad y Tobago</option><option value="1553">Túnez</option><option value="1603">Turkmenistán</option><option value="1586">Turquía</option><option value="1356">Tuvalu</option><option value="1339">Ucrania</option><option value="1685">Uganda</option><option value="1413">Uruguay</option><option value="1602">Uzbekistán</option><option value="1354">Vanuatu</option><option value="1289">Vaticano</option><option value="1640">Venezuela</option><option value="1615">Vietnam</option><option value="1561">Yemen</option><option value="2850">Yibuti</option><option value="1680">Zambia</option><option value="1496">Zimbabue</option></select> </div> <input type="submit" name="op" id="edit-submit-1" value="Ir" class="form-submit" /> <input type="hidden" name="form_build_id" id="form-c9a0e2bd28ac43077b6c753a563ce74f" value="form-c9a0e2bd28ac43077b6c753a563ce74f" /> <input type="hidden" name="form_id" id="edit-amnesty-header-country-select-form" value="amnesty_header_country_select_form" /> </div></form> <!--googleon: all--></div> </div> <!-- /page --> <script type="text/javascript" src="http://www.amnesty.org/sites/impact.amnesty.org/files/js/js_0bbc8e5650ed3a27f914d7f6fb7d0cee.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> <!--//--><![CDATA[//><!-- var gaJsHost = (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://ssl." : "http://www.");document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + gaJsHost + "google-analytics.com/ga.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E")); //--><!]]> </script> <script type="text/javascript"> <!--//--><![CDATA[//><!-- try{var pageTracker = _gat._getTracker("UA-1665647-2");pageTracker._trackPageview();} catch(err) {} //--><!]]> </script> </body> </html>