No justice for grieving victims of police killings in Mozambique
16 November 2009
In a report released today, ‘I can’t believe in justice anymore’: Obstacles to justice for unlawful killings by police in Mozambique, the organization called on the government to make it clear to all members of the police that excessive use of force and unlawful killings will not be tolerated.
Since January 2006, at least 46 people have been unlawfully killed by the police in Mozambique.
Amnesty International also called on the authorities to ensure that families receive proper compensation for their loss.
“The families of victims face almost insurmountable challenges and only the most persistent and well-off have been able to get some small measure of justice. Most others are left without any justice for the loss of their loved ones,” said Erwin van der Borght, Director of Amnesty International’s Africa Programme.
“Even worse, the government seems to have permitted and even encouraged a number of obstacles to be put in the way of victims’ families as they sought justice.”
Despite repeated requests, the authorities have provided Amnesty International with very little information into investigations into police killings in Mozambique, including during visits to the country. In some cases, Amnesty International was told that investigations were not carried out because the killing was presumed to be lawful.
International standards require an effective investigation be carried out into all cases of death or serious injury as a result of use of force or firearms by the police.
Chimène Costa, partner of Augusto Cuvilas, a dancer and choreographer shot and killed by the police in December 2007, told Amnesty International, “I can't believe in justice any more. I am not informed. There is no respect ... They just want us to forget. If you do not have money to pay nothing happens…”.
Lawyers, journalists and human rights activists in Mozambique have all told Amnesty International that the police tend to “protect their own” and that this is one of the main obstacles to bringing police officers to justice.
“The apparent unwillingness of the police to conduct effective investigations into all killings by police, the failure of superior officers to identify police suspected of serious human rights violations, and the tendency of police to protect other officers all contribute to the lack of justice in these cases,” said Erwin van der Borght.
In its report, the organization called on the government to ensure that there are thorough, prompt and impartial investigations into all cases of police force that results in death or serious injury, and that the officers responsible are brought to justice. Families of those killed must also receive adequate reparation.
Other recommendations put forward in the report include that:
- police have access to alternative means to deal with potentially violent situations, so that force used is proportional;
- police are trained in techniques to lower tensions and avoid the use of force unless strictly necessary;
- autopsies are automatically carried out immediately in all cases of death resulting from police force or use of firearms;
- complainants, witnesses, lawyers, judges and others involved in the investigation of police actions are protected from intimidation and reprisals.
Mozambique: 'I can't believe in justice any more': Obstacles to justice for unlawful killings by police in Mozambique
Date Published: 16 November 2009
Unlawful killings have been carried out with near impunity in Mozambique. The authorities have failed to carry out their duty to bring perpetrators to justice, except in the few cases where family members have tenaciously pursued justice or public pressure has forced them into action. The authorities also appear to have allowed obstacles to be placed in the way of families pursuing justice. Amnesty International calls upon the highest authorities in Mozambique to make clear to all members of the police that excessive or arbitrary use of force and extrajudicial executions will not be tolerated.
This document is also available in:Portuguese: