Annual Report 2013
The state of the world's human rights

30 September 2009

Israel leaves crucial questions unanswered as Goldstone report discussed at UN

Israel leaves crucial questions unanswered as Goldstone report discussed at UN
The Israeli authorities must disclose details of the internal investigations they have carried out into the conduct of the Israeli armed forces, Amnesty International said on Wednesday. The call coincides with UN Human Rights Council discussions that started on Tuesday on the Goldstone report on violations of international law committed in Gaza and southern Israel in late December and January.

Judge Goldstone’s report concludes that Israeli armed forces and Palestinian armed groups carried out serious violations of the laws of war, including war crimes and possibly crimes against humanity, and criticizes the failure of both sides to investigate and hold the perpetrators to account.

Amnesty International has written to Israel’s Military Advocate General and Foreign Minister seeking full disclosure regarding investigations into “100 incidents” of alleged violations by Israeli forces.

The Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs said last week – in a special newsletter issued to coincide with the publication of Judge Goldstone’s findings – that these incidents had been investigated by the Israeli authorities. The incidents are said to have included some that were reported by Amnesty International.

“It was surprising to learn about these investigations, as the Israeli authorities have previously failed to respond to our repeated requests for information about investigations into violations alleged to have been committed by their forces,” said Malcolm Smart, Director of the Middle East and North Africa Programme.

“What we need the Israeli authorities to tell us now is which incidents from among the numerous violations alleged have been investigated, and by whom and with what outcome.

“We need to know whether these investigations were in any sense independently conducted or whether they were merely a case of the military investigating itself. In particular, the Israeli authorities need to disclose what steps, if any, their investigators took to obtain evidence from eye-witnesses and victims in Gaza.”

Amnesty International has sent a long list of alleged violations requiring investigation to the Israeli authorities based on the organisation's research in Gaza.

"But we have never received a response nor any request for further information," said Malcolm Smart. "This is despite the fact that the Israeli embassy’s newsletter says that some of the '100 incidents' investigated were ones reported by Amnesty International.”

Read More

Irene Khan urges US government to examine Goldstone report (News, 18 September 2009)
UN must ensure Goldstone inquiry recommendations are implemented (News, 15 September 2009
Lives lost, lives destroyed in Gaza (News, 22 January 2009)
Amnesty International team talks to Gaza survivors (News, 21 January 2009)


Armed Conflict 
Crimes Against Humanity And War Crimes 
Law Enforcement 
Military, Security And Police Equipment 
United Nations 


Israel and Occupied Palestinian Territories 


Middle East And North Africa 

@amnestyonline on twitter


25 January 2015

A failure to protect hundreds of thousands of civilians could lead to a disastrous humanitarian crisis said Amnesty International with reports of two large scale attacks... Read more »

22 January 2015

The Attorney General of Mexico has failed to properly investigate all lines of inquiry into allegations of complicity by armed forces and others in authority in the... Read more »

26 January 2015

Tucked in a dark corner of a secret detention centre in The Philippines was a mock-up of the multicolour wheel used in the "Wheel of Fortune". But rather than spinning for... Read more »

20 January 2015

European governments that cooperated with the CIA’s secret detention, interrogation, and torture operations as part of the USA’s global “war on terror” must act urgently... Read more »

26 January 2015

The health of a prisoner of conscience on hunger strike in Oman has deteriorated seriously, Amnesty International warned ahead of his imminent transfer to the capital... Read more »