Annual Report 2013
The state of the world's human rights

7 September 2011

NATO halts Afghanistan detainee transfers after torture claims

NATO halts Afghanistan detainee transfers after torture claims

NATO’s decision to suspend transferring detainees to Afghan forces due to reports of systematic torture highlights the international community’s failure to provide for basic rule of law in Afghanistan, Amnesty International said today.

The decision was announced on Tuesday after a leaked UN report detailed systematic torture at some government-run detention centres.

Amnesty International has consistently called on the NATO-led ISAF forces to end transfers to facilities run by the Afghan National Directorate of Security (NDS), where torture and other ill-treatment have long been reported.

“Amnesty International warned ISAF of these problems years ago, but instead of fixing the problem, ISAF allowed things deteriorate until the situation became intolerable. ISAF governments should explain how they allowed the situation to get completely out of hand,” said Sam Zarifi, Amnesty International’s Asia-Pacific Director.

“Given the major problems with the lack of legal protection for detainees in US custody in particular, NATO must clarify how it intends to handle detainees, since NATO countries do not operate large detention centers in Afghanistan.”  

NATO has said the suspension involves facilities including police-run prisons in Kunduz and Tarin Kowt as well as NDS-run prisons in Herat, Khost, Lagman, Kapisa and Takhar and a counter-terrorism facility known as Department 124.

According to the UN report, detainees at those sites were regularly beaten with rubber hoses and threatened with sexual assault. Many of those targeted were suspected of being insurgents.

A spokesperson for the United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA), told the media the UN had already handed over its findings to the Afghan government, which is taking the matter "very seriously."

NATO officials have said they will investigate the torture claims.

ISAF forces are due to be withdrawn from Afghanistan over the coming years, giving national authorities responsibility for providing for the security of Afghans.

“Any security handover must be contingent on the authorities in Afghanistan meeting basic benchmarks for human rights and the rule of law,” said Sam Zarifi.

“Before international forces leave, ISAF and the international community must help reform Afghanistan’s prison system to ensure that detainees’ human rights are respected.  Afghan authorities must thoroughly investigate any allegations of arbitrary detentions and torture in custody, especially at NDS facilities, and bring those responsible to justice.”

Amnesty International called on NATO to grant detainees in its custody in Afghanistan adequate access to lawyers and their families, as well as any medical treatment or consular assistance where needed.

“In areas of Afghanistan controlled by the Taleban and other insurgent groups, detainees regularly face horrific abuses. But Afghans are now asking how it is that their government, with all the international support it receives, has also resorted to torture and ill-treatment of prisoners,” said Sam Zarifi.

Read More

Afghanistan: Authorities must look to the International Criminal Court to prosecute Taleban attacks (Press release, 29 June 2011)
Afghanistan: NATO Summit must protect basic human rights (Press release, 18 November 2010)
Afghanistan leak exposes NATO's incoherent civilian casualty policy (News, 26 July 2010)




Asia And The Pacific 


Armed Conflict 
International Organizations 
Prison Conditions 
Torture And Ill-treatment 


Security with Human Rights 

@amnestyonline on twitter


30 January 2015

Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe should use his position as the Chairperson of the African Union to address key human rights concerns in different parts of the... Read more »

22 January 2015

The Attorney General of Mexico has failed to properly investigate all lines of inquiry into allegations of complicity by armed forces and others in authority in the... Read more »

26 January 2015

Tucked in a dark corner of a secret detention centre in The Philippines was a mock-up of the multicolour wheel used in the "Wheel of Fortune". But rather than spinning for... Read more »

30 January 2015

The UK authorities must respond urgently to a statement today by a former Bush Administration staffer that interrogations of CIA detainees took place on the British... Read more »

30 January 2015

Last night’s royal decree offering pardons for Saudi Arabian prisoners convicted on “public rights” charges will only be a step in the right direction if the releases do not... Read more »