Annual Report 2013
The state of the world's human rights

13 January 2010

Acquittal of UAE sheikh on abuse charges 'lacked transparency'

Acquittal of UAE sheikh on abuse charges 'lacked transparency'
Amnesty International questioned Sunday’s decision by a court in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) to acquit a sheikh and member of Abu Dhabi’s ruling family who was charged with causing the assault and rape of a man in 2004.

Sheikh Issa bin Zayed al-Nahyan, was acquitted by a court in Al-'Ain of endangering the life, “causing bodily harm and rape" of Mohammad Shah Poor, an Afghan businessman with whom he had a dispute.

The court ruled that he had been acting under the influence of drugs administered by associates who wished to film and then blackmail him, and that he therefore had “diminished liability” for the violent and sustained assault on the Afghan victim.

At one point during the assault, the film showed one of his attackers driving a motor vehicle over Mohammad Shah Poor as he lay on the ground injured by the assault.

“We were not in court and so cannot be certain as to the judge’s reasoning, but this does appear to be a very questionable verdict”, said Malcolm Smart, Director of Amnesty International’s Middle East and North Africa programme.

“It will do little to dispel concern that the sheikh’s position as a member of Abu Dhabi’s ruling family may have been the decisive factor in ensuring his acquittal, especially as it took the authorities several years even to bring the prosecution.”

Sheikh Issa holds no official position in the UAE but he is a half-brother of the country's President.

Film of the assault was first circulated several years ago but it was only in April last year, after part of it was shown on ABC television’s Nightline programme in the USA prompting calls for accountability, that the UAE authorities took steps to prosecute him.

At the time, the UAE authorities acknowledged that they were already aware of the assault but said that they had not launched a criminal investigation because they had been informed that the matter had been resolved privately between Sheikh Issa and his victim. .

The sheikh was charged together with six others, including Bassam and Ghassan Nabulsi, two Lebanese-American brothers who were formerly business associates of the sheikh.

In his defence, the sheikh alleged that they had drugged him in order to have him commit criminal acts which they filmed in order to blackmail him.

The Nabulsi brothers, who now reside in the USA, are both reported to deny this; however, the court accepted the sheikh’s allegations and convicted them in their absence, sentenced them to five years imprisonment and fined them 10,000 dirham (US$2,723).

A Nepalese guard seen in the video was also acquitted by the court, but three other accused - a Syrian, an Indian and a Palestinian – were convicted and sentenced to prison terms.

The former received a one year sentence for assaulting the Afghan, Mohammad Shah Poor, the other two were sentenced to three years’ imprisonment for sodomising him.

The film footage shows Mohammad Shah Poor being shot at, having sand forced into his mouth and being struck with a cattle prod and a wooden plank with a nail in it, and having salt forcibly rubbed into his wounds, then being driven over by a car.

The incident is believed to have taken place in the desert near Abu Dhabi where Sheikh Issa owns a ranch.  The assault is alleged to have been committed as a result of a business dispute between Sheikh Issa and Mohammad Shah Poor.

Read More

Member of United Arab Emirates ruling family implicated in 'torture' video (News, 1 May 2009)

Issue

Torture And Ill-treatment 
Trials And Legal Systems 

Country

UAE 

Region

Middle East And North Africa 

@amnestyonline on twitter

News

18 September 2014

Nigeria’s police and military routinely torture women, men, and children – some as young as 12 – using a wide range of methods including beatings, shootings and rape... Read more »

04 September 2014

For years Amnesty International has been investigating and recording evidence of torture in Mexico. Here're some of the most shocking facts. 

Read more »
18 September 2014

The conviction of four peaceful protesters by a Thai military court today is an affront to justice and another sign of repression under military rule. 

Read more »
15 September 2014

European leaders must do more to provide safe and legal ways for refugees and migrants to access international protection in the European Union.

Read more »
18 September 2014

A controversial new cybercrimes law that criminalizes the spreading of “false news” on the internet poses a serious threat to freedom of expression in Qatar.

Read more »