Document - Brazil: "They come in Shooting": Policing socially excluded communities\r\nFacts and Figures and Case Studies

BRAZIL Brazil: "They come in Shooting": Policing socially excluded communities Facts and Figures and Case Studies

AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL
PRESS RELEASE


AI Index: AMR 19/033/2005 (Public)
News Service No: 309
2 December 2005

Embargo Date: 2 December 2005 13:00 GMT

Brazil: “They come in Shooting”: Policing socially excluded communities
Facts and Figures and Case Studies
FACTS AND FIGURES
Violence and crime

Social disparities
  • By 1998, the richest 20 per cent of the country had a 64.4 per cent share of income or consumption while the poorest 20 per cent had only 2 per cent.
  • The homicide rate in Brazil’s urban centres is amongst the highest in the world.
  • In 2002 alone, there were almost 50,000 homicides, while hundreds of thousands of people were violently attacked or robbed.
  • The murder rate is concentrated in areas of greater socio-economic exclusion and reduced police presence.
  • In the city of São Paulo, Jardim Ângela, a socially deprived district in the south of the city, suffered 309 homicides or 123 per 100,000 in 2001, while the middle class district of Moema, only a few kilometres away, suffered 2 homicides or 3 per 100,000 in the same year.
  • Private ownership of bullet-proof cars in Brazil is among the highest in the world.

Police violence
  • Official statistics show that between 1999 and 2004, police in the states of Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo killed 9,889 people in situations registered officially as “resistance followed by death”.
  • As a result of this, 558 police officers in Rio de Janeiro were punished. 14 of them were expelled from the police.
  • Police officers are also at high risk of attacks. In Rio de Janeiro, 52 police officers were killed on duty in 2004 alone.

Victims of police violence – profile
  • The majority of the victims of police violence are poor, black or mixed race youths many without any criminal record.
  • According to UNESCO, 93 per cent of all homicide victims in Brazil in 2000 were male. Youths aged 15 to 24 are 30 times more likely to be victims of homicide. Black youths suffer double the number of homicides. Of the 17,900 youths who were victims of homicides in 2002, 11,308 were black while 6,592 were white.

Massacres
2005 Baixada Fluminense – 29 people killed by a “death squad”.
1997 Eldorado dos Carajás -- land activists murdered.
1993 Candelaria Cathedral -- children sleeping on the steps of the church are murdered.
1993 Vigário Geral -- favela dwellers
1992 Carandiru prision - unarmed detainees in São Paulo’s detention centre are murdered.
Countless other killings have gone unreported.

Small arms
  • There are around 17 million small arms held in Brazil of which 15 million are held privately. Of those around 9 million are held illegally; 4 million are believed to be held by criminals.
  • In Rio de Janeiro police confiscated 3,891 revolvers between 1960 and 1969. This increased to 53,526 between 1990 and 2001.
  • While the majority of guns seized are revolvers and pistols, there has been a marked rise in the number of high-velocity weapons, including assault rifles, machine guns and sub-machine guns.
  • Police have also found grenades, mortars, bazookas and land mines in the hands of drug factions, some believed to have been stolen or illegally obtained from the military.
  • Brazil is the largest manufacturer and exporter of small arms in the region. Around three-quarters of the weapons apprehended by the police are made in Brazil.
  • A recent statement by the head of Rio de Janeiro’s police intelligence unit claimed that 80% of arms in the favelas of Rio de Janeiro are coming from Paraguay, where controls on the sales of guns are much more relaxed. This includes firearms manufactured in Brazil which are exported to Paraguay and then illegally smuggled back into the country.
  • In July 2004, the government launched a disarmament campaign. By June 2005, 356,139 guns had been collected across the country and destroyed.

Public security
  • In May 2005, a survey by the Universidade Federal Fluminense found that 30 per cent of the population partially or fully accepted the concept that “a good criminal is a dead criminal”.
  • In April 2005, Marcelo Itagiba, State Secretary of Public Security of Rio de Janeiro said that “if the police are more active they will kill more people”.

CASE STUDIES
Police killings
Five youths, including a 13-year-old boy, were killed on 6 January 2004, in the favela of Cajú in the north of Rio de Janeiro. One surviving witness and several family members informed the police that two policemen had rushed, shooting, towards the five while they were sitting in a bar. The boys tried to identify themselves to no avail. On 7 January, their bodies were found in a mud pit, located behind a garage near the community. A police investigation was opened into the killing. Shortly after reporting what had taken place the one surviving witness, who had himself been shot, left the community with his family saying they feared the police.

In April 2005, Amnesty International met Elizabete Maria de Souza, a mother of three, and sister of the dead 13-year-old. She said that she was unable to sleep at night as she feared for the safety of her three daughters, only resting for brief periods in the morning before going to work. She told Amnesty International delegates that police patrols regularly passed her house slowing down as they approached. She further said that she was now looking for a means to take her daughters away from the community so that they could be safe.

Police invasions in Favelas
At five o’clock in the morning of 28 August 2005, members of São Paulo’s military police invaded Jardim Elba, a favela in Sapopemba in the east of São Paulo. Sapopemba’s inhabitants described the incident:

“It was as if there was a war. Police invading our “favela” from top to bottom and from bottom to top. The streets were blocked, as the military police on horseback blocked all pedestrian access.”

The authorities later informed community leaders that the operation “Saturation”, was aimed at combating drug trafficking in the community and ensuring closer links between residents and the police. A press statement on São Paulo’s state secretariat of public security’s web-site stated that police had stopped and questioned 4,797 people, while they had searched 474 cars, 401 motorcycles and 210 business establishments.

However, Sapopemba’s social movements denounced that human rights violations took place during the operation, including: entering houses without warrants; abusive and violent searches of women; and the confiscation or discarding of residents’ packed lunches.


Public Document
****************************************
For more information please call Amnesty International's press office in London, UK, on +44 20 7413 5566
Amnesty International, 1 Easton St., London WC1X 0DW. web: http://www.amnesty.org

For latest human rights news view http://news.amnesty.org






Amnesty International, International Secretariat, 1 Easton Street, WC1X 0DW, London, United Kingdom